Today we had a lesson in racial offensiveness.
Isaac told me this morning that two boys at school (good friends of his, not bullies in the least) called him "Monkey Boy". Some of you reading this may gasp, as I did. And others of you may think "So?" Which is why I write this post. Now, I do not believe these boys at 5 years old knew the racial implication of this name, nor did Isaac. But I do believe, and he did as well, that they chose this name because he has brown skin. Before I tell you what I chose to do about this, I want to address "why do anything at all?" You may yourself not know what the racist implication of this phrase is, but it is a long standing terminology that white people used to describe black people. And it IS offensive, whether meant to be or not. Here is a great blog post on this topic, where people have depicted Obama as a monkey. Please read it. It states far better than I can, why this is a racially offensive term and image. I especially like the quote they use that says,
Now, how does this apply to little kids who don't know better? Well...the only way for us to become educated is to educate. And although it is not my place to educate another's child, I was able to use it as a way to educate mine. So I said to Isaac, "why do you think they called you that?" and he said "because I have brown skin." I then told him that the term "monkey" is offensive to African American people and that I do not want anyone to call him that. I said "Some people think it is funny to call African American's 'monkey' for several reasons, but it is not funny." I told him to tell his friends that they are not to ever call him or anyone with brown skin monkey and to let the teacher know. After school, I told his teacher. She responded in a way I hoped she would and agreed that it was not appropriate. I told her I don't want to make a big deal about it, but I did want her to know in case it ever came up in class. I explained that I know the children do not know what they are saying and that white families typically do not discuss race or racial offensive comments with their kids, but that our family does."Because whether the racism comes from
ignorance and a lack of knowledge of
people who are different from you or a person had a run-in with a black person
that wasn't good, and then applies that to the whole race, its going to be very challenging for Americans to confront their stuff," ~Amy Alexander.
With the huge popularity in monkey apparel, it is increasingly hard to find things that do not have monkey images on them, especially in toddler sizes. But my boys have never and will never wear monkey clothes, no matter how cute they are. Again, read the blog above for an explanation. Caucasian children can be called "cute little monkey" all their parents want to...but please do not call my boys, monkeys.

23 friends commented!:
My little R is 18 months old. Last night, at Halloween, we pointed out all the dressed up creatures that she would recognize as they came trick-or-treating. One little boy (probably 3) was dressed as a monkey. As I said to her, "Look R, that little boy is a monkey," I noticed he had dark brown skin. I almost stopped saying it, but continued because, well, he was a monkey last night. But I still felt really... awkward(?) saying it.
I was kind of appalled that his parents would dress him up as a monkey being that I thought the very thing that your post illustrates.
I can see your point. When my kids were little and climbing on everything I would call them a Monkey but in the sense of the animal.
I shared this story with Sierra. She said "momma I would never say that if we lived by them I would give him a hug!" Thank you for this post as I took it to heart and Mr. Campbell and I touched base with Sierra on this issue. I sure do hope that one day our kiddos can meet so they can be real life friend;)
You may have read this book already, but I'm a huge fan of it -- "I'm Chocolate, You're Vanilla" by Marguerite Wright. The author's goal is teaching African-American and biracial children to have a healthy racial picture of themselves. It's fantastic, and provides and examination of children's perceptions of color and race by age and stage. I especially love all the interviews with children that she includes.
Just wanted to pass along a recommendation if you hadn't read it yet!
Nancy
OMG! I totally agree. Levi will NEVER wear anything with a monkey on it. We have made a conscience efforst not to do this. I was on another blog and mom has an adopted son (that she just adopted form Africa) She dressed him as a monkey costume and it made me crindge...I so badly want to say something, but I don't know what to say. Thank you so much for this post! It is much needed and well written.
Nancy, yes we own it. It is THE book we recommend for transracial adoptive parents. SO good. In my Transracial Adoption label on my sidebar, I have written many posts on this topic for anyone interested in reading them!
Our Journey, I know the blog you mentioned and it's been brought to her attention before and she doesn't care. Says they've always called all kids in the family monkey and will call their son monkey as well. Makes me very sad for him.
Glad his teacher was supportive. Interesting that even though Isaac didn't know why it was not nice to call him that he knew it wasn't right. Glad he told you about it. You do an excellent job teaching your children.
On the topic a question, Dave and I were talking recently about what terms to use; chocolate, brown, etc... and he said it didn't really matter which it doesn't. But I told him that I'm making a point to use these terms with Isabel. If I say she's chocolate I'm vanilla. Or she's brown and I'm white. Do you think that's a good thing to start pointing out at her age? My thinking is just like telling her adoption story, it will just make it easier to use the words and talk about when things come up. Know what I mean?
Debbie, you told me about that blog. That is a sad deal, indeed.
As far as talking about race to a toddler, we did! Some thought it not necessary, "why bring race into the picture? It doesn't matter what color of skin anyone has!" the naysayers will point out. Well...it does matter, especially in a multiracial family. So I would point out kids in books and magazines and say "Look Isaac he has brown skin like you and she has light skin like mommy." Those are the terms we used. I'm not white and he is not black, so I don't use those words to describe us, but I will say "white people and black people" along with Caucasian and African American, because that is an accepted way to describe racial groups in our culture...hope that makes sense! I choose not to use food words because "chocolate" means something else around here with Mama's addiction to it!
Talking about race from toddlerhood means that isaac has no problem bringing it up, and Vivi doesn't either. Talking about race means that when things like this come up, your child will want to talk about it, because it is not a taboo topic.
Thanks, sounds like I'm on the right track.
Laurie,
I stop by your blog from time to time and I just wanted to encourage you. Your post is completely on point.
I think you were rightfully appalled and you handled the situation perfectly. Words and images have power and history. There's a reason black people were referred to as monkeys and not some other random animal like pandas or kangaroos.
I really think you're doing a great job to create a safe place in your home and a healthy racial identity for your kids.
Thank you for your kind words, Anonymous. They were encouraging!! We do our best to remain racially aware without making "everything about race" as some may accuse those of us parenting African American children of doing.
Meaghan,
Thank you so much for sharing your opinion! I don't get a lot of negative comments on my blog and I am not naive enough to think people do not disagree with my opinion, they just don't choose to share theirs. So I appreciate you doing so. I don't think the issue is whether or not another family has a right to dress their child any way they like, that is a given. The issue at hand is not good parenting or bad parenting, it is being racially aware when you choose to take on the God given privilege of parenting a child that is not your same race. I gather by your words about "reverse racism" that you yourself are caucasian, that is a common phrase I have heard from other white women. What i hope you understand from my post, and the blog I linked, is that we are not "teaching our child that other children are being racist." because as I said, I do not believe they were. You do not have to teach racism, however. I know it is hard for those of us who have never had to face someone seeing us differently simply because of the color of our skin, but it DOES happen. It does not have to be taught to them, they will experience it. And you have to hear me when I say, white children being called "monkey" does not have a long standing cultural stigma like calling a black child that. It is not an issue of everyone being equal, it is a derogatory phrase meant to demean a people group. I will not tolerate my child being demeaned, whether someone does in intentionally or not. It is not me being overly sensitive, it is me being an advocate for my child, just like I would if I had a chubby child and kids wanted to call him/her "Shamu". This just so happens to do with race and not body size.
Hi Anonymous,
Nice to meet you and your incredibly uninformed comment. I see you have come over here from Leah's blog (whom I knew nothing about until today, but have since been in contact with via email), because anyone reading my blog for any length of time would know that I do not think my kids are victims, and calling them that is offensive. "Every white person, except me, hates that black people think they are victims? Wow. really? Cause I was raised white, in a white family, with white friends and I don't remember anyone ever saying they hated the fact that black people think they are victims. Victims of what? Your arrogance and white privilege? Strong words...yes, words have incredible meaning and history behind them, which was the point of my blogpost. Did you click on the link I mentioned? I can see not. And you are very, very wrong that kids do not see skin color. They are not colorblind. That is a statement that white people make to sound anti-racist. Kids see skin color like every other person. When they are raised in an environment that celebrates peoples differences, they grow up to be adults who embrace difference instead of running from it. Why don't you become informed about racial issues in America before you read a strangers blog and spout off your ignorance. And I will "whine" to my son's kindergarten teacher every single time I feel something has happened at school that was inappropriate. If you are ok with your kids being called derogatory names at school, that is your perogative. I am not. Feel free to read my Transracial Adoption posts on my right sidebar before you leave any more uneducated comments.
To deny Isaac's 'color' or ethnicity would be to deny him of how God created him. Teaching him about skin color and race is important in not only valuing his heritage, taking pride in who he is, but also in helping him face the world when people will not be so kind.
Some of these readers are insinuating that teaching him these valuable things is 'bad' and we should all be viewed "the same" or "color-blind." So they are basically saying that teaching him 'the truth' about his ethnicity is not teaching equality? hmmm...think about that one folks.
Treating people equally is one thing, but assuming kids don't see color and ignoring race in a family is setting that child up for hurt, confusion and frustration for the future.
Isaac is not color-blind. He is smart, he knows what he sees in the mirror everyday, and to ignore it implies that something is wrong: "I know I look different but why does my family ignore it? What's wrong with me? Why do people call me names? Why can't I talk to my mom or dad about this?" - this is not what I would want my child to say or think!!!
For Isaac to have the freedom to talk to his parents about his appearance and race is one of the most healthiest things they could do for his development of self-esteem as a african american child. Race should be celebrated! Why deny him of the awesomeness that God created him to be....a strong, kind, smart, christian (african american) boy.
If the tables were turned, (if I was adopted by two african american parents and lived in a mostly african american community/state/country) I would want my parents to teach me about my skin color, race, ethnicity from a young age. And celebrate it! It's how God created me! Because they would be teaching me that being different is not bad, it is something to cherish and have pride in how I was created AND how I am alike AND different. Wake up folks, we are different from one another. Celebrate it, don't ignore it.
It's the households of families that don't teach about skin color/ethnicity/race that I worry about the most. You know the video's showing the research studies of children and race: (here is the link on youtube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MqSFqnUFOns or google 'black or white something to think about')...when they held up dolls and asked the children "who is the prettiest?" and/or " who is the bad guy" You can guess the results. (white - pretty/black-not so much) (white- good guy/black - bad guy) Kids know color and they are having perceptions that we are not cluing into!!! Teachable moments are passing us by, especially if we ignore this and take on a "color-blind" view. These readers need to get out of La La land (we are all the same-land) and come down to reality and address these important issues.
My (Caucasian) daughters who now live in a small farm town (with no African american children in their classes) are very aware of Isaac, and J and the color of their skin. And I don't ignore it. I talk with them, we discuss it, we celebrate God's creation and how different he made each and everyone of us. (teachable moments!!!)
I have watched Laurie and Billy CELEBRATE their children's lives, their personalities, and you better believe their ethnicity. And their children have and will continue to have self-esteem that is built on love, trust and truth.
PS. If my daughter was calling an african american kid "monkey" at school, I would HOPE that the parent of that child would say something to the teacher and to me. Why pass on this very important teachable moment?
If you don't agree with me....don't waste your breath in replying to me. I'm too tired and too sick to argue. I pray for you specifically.
You are not being oversensitive and my children, like yours, will never monkey clothes. Kudos for you for advocating and teaching your child so that he can appropriately respond to racism in the future. Anyone who wants to believe that the world is colorblind is in denial of their own prejudices (directed at anonymous)..
Diana
Anon, it's not about teaching them they are a different skin color. It's about preparing them for the world that awaits them. It's about educating ourselves as parents to better parent our children.
Children might not know any better but teenagers do and adults do. So we're just supposed to let them blindly go into the world knowing nothing about the racism that is still in this country. I think not.
Until you've experienced it don't speak out so strongly against what a parent is doing.
Thank you, ladies for your words and the courage to speak the truth. The fact that Anonymous keeps coming back here to join in the dicussion says something! Based on her latest comment, however...I will not publish one more word from her, not because I can't take her on...I have shown I can. But because she has clearly shown her stereotypes and prejudices and my family blog where I post my children's adorable faces and stories will not be a forum for racist rants.
you can't just pretend that stereotypes/racism do not exist. they do exist and the feelings that come along with them are very real. you can't just teach your children to ignore that problems exist and they w...ill go away.
what kind of lesson is that? i think that is what meaghan / anonymous is leaning towards. "let's just ignore the problems that we have with race in this country and race will not be an issue". that kind of mentality. that's such an ignorant mindset. and it teaches children to play into the "victim" role? really? ugh.
i don't know you that well, but i really don't think that your children will everrrr think of themselves as victims, no matter what race they are. you are simply teaching your children that we all need to be sensitive to these things and to the feelings of others. and i think that's pretty great. :)
the fact that anonymous wants to remain anonymous says something. everyone has a right to their opinion...no matter how uneducated and ignorant that opinion is.
just saying.
Thank you for posting this. As a soon to be adoptive mom of an African child, I need to be much more aware of these things. My two other boys have all kinds of clothes with monkeys on them but our newest addition will not be wearing those when he comes home.
I don't think anonymous came over from my blog. . . But I guess I can't say for sure.
I can say this. We are all ignorant, and all we can do is try to educate ourselves as best as possible. I have so much to learn, and I know raising my children, I will continue to be humbled by all I do not know.
Everything in life is a learning opportunity, and all we can try to do is teach people with kindness. Maybe I'm overly optimistic, but I do believe that most people are good people and mean well.
What I have learned, is that many people think that monkey is not an okay term to use for my African child. Until a few days ago, I had never heard that feedback. Ever. And I'd been referring to my child as monkey since I started my blog. But my mind is open and it's definitely something I will continue to think about, and try to be sensitive to.
We should never read another blog though and assume things about people. Don't read my blog and assume I'm a racist. (not saying you did that, I'm just making a point) Instead, use it as an opportunity to educate. We all have things to learn in life. I'm learning something new every day.
Leah,
you are right that anon. probably didn't come from your blog. They ended up flooding my comment box with racial slurs about my kids that I would never publish. I can't imagine they would choose to read your blog or mine if they are full blown racist, as their comments showed.
And I promise, NO ONE thinks you are racist. You adopted a baby from Africa, a racist wouldn't do that. It is brave of you to come here and comment and admit that you just didn't know any better. You are right we are all learning! The great thing about this blog community is that some of us have walked this road longer and we can learn from that. I know I have!
I can say with 100% certainty that I truly did not know the term was derogatory, and I'm so happy that a couple people choose to alert that to me when I posted my Halloween post. I have a feeling many of my readers were a bit taken aback, but didn't want to offend me. Well, I wasn't offended at all! And I'd still be using the term had someone not pointed it out to me.
I have a feeling this is the first of MANY lessons I will receive as I navigate this new world of raising my children.
Post a Comment